Ice Cream Sandwich Party on Recipe Renovator | How to prep for an ice cream party, make ice cream sandwiches, and have a blast in the summer heat

How to host an ice cream party featuring ice cream sandwiches

For my birthday this year, we celebrated with an ice cream party. To keep things simple, I made four different kinds of ice cream sandwiches in advance, then made sorbet at the party and invited people to bring ice cream, sundae toppings, root beer float ingredients, whatever they wanted. It was the perfect hot summer day, and everyone had fun.

How to throw an ice cream party

Some ice cream party tips:

  • Buy dry ice by the pound at the grocery store on the day of your party (not before, as it off-gasses). Place a few packages of dry ice on the bottom level of your cooler, then add regular ice on top. If it’s not a super-hot day, regular bags of ice work just fine.
  • Clean out your freezer in advance of the party so you have an empty shelf for ice cream that arrives with guests.
  • If you have guests on special diets, label your specialty ice cream sandwiches and put them in a separate cooler (gluten-free, dairy-free, vegan).
  • Keep the drinks simple and low-sugar, since the ice cream is the star. I had some cold brew coffee, fizzy water, a cocktail, and watermelon lemonade.
  • Stock up on spoons, small cups, and lots of napkins.
  • Having a package of wet naps on hand is helpful.
  • Bubbles are great fun for the kids on a hot day.
  • Don’t have coolers? A heavy box with a lid lined with a plastic garbage bag will work with dry ice and ice.

Foxys Ice Cream review on Recipe Renovator | Gluten-free, small batch, lower sugar, probiotic

Foxy’s Ice Cream review:

I was contacted by a new Southern California company called Foxy’s Thoughtful Ice Cream. They make small-batch, hand-crafted, probiotic premium ice cream. It’s gluten-free and lower in sugar than something like Ben & Jerry’s or Haagen-Dazs. They sent me six flavors to try. The Rocky Road is absolutely the best I have ever tasted (the hand-made marshmallows really make it sing.) Every flavor, even the simple vanilla, is just lovely. You can order Foxy’s online here.

Ice cream sandwich flavor combos and tips:

  • Foxy’s California Pistachio ice cream with Lucy’s lemon cookies (GF)
  • Foxy’s Oregon Cherry Vanilla ice cream with Lucy’s cinnamon cookies (GF)
  • Coconut Bliss chocolate-peanut butter ice cream with Uncle Eddie’s Vegan chocolate chip cookies (vegan/dairy-free)
  • Foxy’s Uncle Mike’s Double Chocolate Ice Cream with Whole Foods Toffee Pizzelles
  • One pint of ice cream makes 14-15 small ice cream sandwiches.
  • Ice cream with add-ins that freeze solid (like natural peanut butter) are tough to scoop.
  • Label bags in advance so that guests can pick their own flavors.
  • If you have guests coming with food allergies, make them something they can eat like fruit sorbet.
  • I taped the ingredient lists from my special ice cream and cookies to index cards for guests that needed that level of detail.

Ice Cream Sandwich party on Recipe Renovator

You might also like:

Vanilla bean ice cream sandwiches (dairy-free, grain-free, paleo, gluten-free)
Margarita ice cream sandwiches from Cooking Light
Chocolate chip ice cream sandwiches from Family Spice

Required FTC disclosure: Foxy’s Thoughtful Ice Cream sent me six pints to taste. I was under no obligation to write a review, do a post, or take photographs. I was not paid to write this post.

Ice cream sandwiches | Ice cream party on Recipe Renovator

Ice cream sandwiches

How to host an ice cream party featuring ice cream sandwiches, with tips and tricks for keeping it simple in the heat. Review of Foxy's ice cream.
5 from 1 vote
Prep Time 5 mins
Total Time 1 hr 5 mins
Course Lunch
Cuisine American
Servings 14 sandwiches


  • 1 pint ice cream
  • 28 cookies


  • Freeze a lined baking sheet for at least an hour. This is your work surface.
  • Freeze your cookies as well.
  • If it's very hot in your kitchen (do this at night on hot days), work with no more than 3 sandwiches at a time.
  • Lay out your cookies baked-side up on the frozen sheet.
    Making ice cream sandwiches on Recipe Renovator
  • Using a small scoop, form one level scoop for each cookie and place it flat side down onto the cookie.
    Making ice cream sandwiches on Recipe Renovator
  • Gently press a second cookie on top, squishing the ice cream gently to the edges of the cookie as much as possible.
    Making ice cream sandwiches on Recipe Renovator
  • Freeze on the tray. Then put into labelled zip top bags.